Sports card investing typically involves buying and selling sports cards in the hope that the cards you collect will increase in value over time. If you collect sports cards as a hobby, you might be interested in exploring how your collection could fold into your overall investment strategy, if at all, and considering its potential to generate returns over time.
Are sports cards a good investment? They may be for investors who understand how the market for sports cards works and how to identify investment opportunities. Like any other investment, however, there are some risks to be aware of, especially when it comes to alternative investments like sports cards. Here’s a closer look at how investing in sports cards works.
Key Points
• Sports cards originated in the 19th century, initially used for marketing.
• By the 1980s, collecting and investing in sports cards became increasingly popular.
• Card value is influenced by player performance, popularity, scarcity, and condition.
• Professional grading services assess card condition, enhancing market transparency.
• Sports cards offer portfolio diversification and potential returns, appealing to passionate investors.
History of Investing in Sports Cards
Sports cards have a lengthy history, dating back to the 19th century. The earliest known baseball card was issued in 1865 by the Brooklyn Atlantics, who were dominant in the New York City sports scene at the time, according to Library of Congress records. The team’s “carte de visit,” or visiting card, was handed out to fans as souvenirs.
More athletic organizations followed suit, issuing sets of trading cards featuring lithographic portraits and later, photographic prints of individual players. These early sports card sets were often included in packs of candy or tobacco and were used as a marketing tactic by companies to get consumers to buy their products.
Interest in sports card trading grew throughout the early 20th century, and collectors began to realize how valuable these cards could be. Baseball cards were joined by football cards, and later, basketball cards. By the 1980s, the market for sports cards investing and trading was beginning to take off. Investing in sports cards and other sports memorabilia has become a way to diversify and potentially generate returns, outside of traditional stocks and bonds.
As an alternative investment, sports cards offer the potential to combine your investment strategy with your passions if you’re a true sports enthusiast. But it’s important to know that alternative investments can be high risk, and whether or not sports card investing provides returns can depend on a number of factors. (SoFi offers funds with alternative investments, but it does not offer sports card investing.)
Recommended: Alt Investment Guide
The Sports Card Market
Sports card investments are seeing a resurgence in recent years, and as of 2023, the sports trading card market generated $14.8 billion in revenue. That number is expected to grow to more than $51 billion by 2033. Some of the most sought-after cards in the market trade for millions of dollars, including a T206 Honus Wagner baseball card which sold for $6.606 million at auction in 2021.
The sports card investment market extends to not only baseball or football cards, but a variety of other trading cards including:
• Character cards
• Image cards
• Autograph cards
• Pokémon cards
• Magic: The Gathering cards
• Yu-Gi-Oh! cards
• Cardfight! Vanguard cards
Some of these specialty cards rival the performance of the most in-demand sports cards. One of the rarest and most valuable Pokémon cards, for instance, was valued at $5.275 million at auction.
How to Invest in Sports Cards
Investing in sports cards typically involves simply buying them. You can buy packs of cards, or even boxes, and then open those packs to see what’s in them – essentially, hoping that you’ll find a rare or valuable card. You can also go out on the market and try to track down specific cards that have value, or that you believe have value. Perhaps they’re selling for under market rate, or you believe they’ll be worth more in the future than you’d pay for them now? In that case, you can make an investment and hope it pays off.
In effect, though, buying cards is really the only way to invest in sports cards. You could also look into buying fractional shares of certain high-value cards on some investment platforms, too.
Key Factors That Influence Card Value
An obvious key to success when you invest in sports cards is knowing what’s valuable — and what’s not. There’s one simple rule of thumb to remember: Sports cards are worth what someone is willing to pay for them.
Sports card valuations are determined by a variety of factors, including their age and rarity. Developing a trained eye can help with your decision-making when trading investment sports cards.
Player Performance and Popularity
Player performance and popularity can make a difference in how much a sports card commands at an auction or in the trading market. A card featuring a high-profile player with an impressive list of career achievements is likely to have a higher valuation than the card of an average player.
Savvy collectors consider not just current but future popularity when deciding which cards to invest in. For example, they might buy up rookie cards for a number one draft pick if expectations are high that the player will have a stellar career.
Scarcity also factors in. Limited edition or autographed cards may hold more value and appeal for collectors if there are fewer of them in the trading market.
Card Condition and Grading
The card’s condition also factors in when determining what a sports card investment is worth. Cards that are in mint condition, for instance, generally have a higher value than a card that has some minor wear and tear.
It’s possible for sports card investors to have their cards professionally graded. Grading is the process of having a professional evaluate your cards to determine what they’re worth and rating them on a scale of 1 to 10. The higher the grade, the better the condition the card is in and the more it’s likely to be worth.
A perfect “10 card” would have:
• Four perfectly-sharp corners
• A correctly-centered image that is in sharp focus
• No damage or wear to its original coating
• No staining
• No writing or stray in/pencil marks
Professional grading services know exactly what to look for, including how to spot fake cards which is one of the biggest risks associated with alt investments in sports cards.
Risks and Challenges in the Sports Card Market
Is collecting sports cards a good investment? Most investments carry some degree of risk and sports are no different.
If you’re interested in how to get into sports card investing it’s important to understand these risk factors:
• Counterfeiting/fraud. Sports cards are a target for counterfeiting, which could put you at risk of making a bad investment if you can’t tell the difference between a fake and the real thing.
• Inaccurate grading. You may rely on a pro grading service to tell you what your sports cards are worth, but it’s possible they could get it wrong. If the grader’s assessment is incorrect your cards could end up over or undervalued.
• Volatility and unpredictability. The sports card trading market can be unpredictable and card valuations don’t always hold steady. If a player has a poor season, for instance, or gets traded to an underwhelming team, that could affect the value of your collectible cards and lead to a lower than expected rate of return.
Lastly, there’s the risk of simply getting it wrong. You might believe that a particular player’s card values are going to take off so you sink a chunk of money into buying them. Only, their career doesn’t go as planned or the market takes an unexpected turn and now you’re out the money that you’ve invested.
Recommended: Alternative Investment Definition
The Takeaway
You have different options for how to invest in sports cards, including buying cards at auction, trading through online marketplaces, or opting for digital versions with non-fungible tokens (NFTs). Regardless of your investing preferences, think about how much risk you’re comfortable taking on and what percentage of your portfolio you want to dedicate to sports card investments for the short and long term.
Ready to expand your portfolio's growth potential? Alternative investments, traditionally available to high-net-worth individuals, are accessible to everyday investors on SoFi's easy-to-use platform. Investments in commodities, real estate, venture capital, and more are now within reach. Alternative investments can be high risk, so it's important to consider your portfolio goals and risk tolerance to determine if they're right for you.
FAQ
How important is card grading in sports card investing?
One of the first things you’ll hear about when researching how to start investing in sports cards is grading. Grading is what sets the standard for how much a sports card or another type of trading card is worth. There are numerous companies that offer grading services and it’s important to research them carefully to find a reputable grader to work with.
What sports typically have the most valuable cards?
Some of the most valuable sports card investments have historically been baseball cards, which makes sense since those were the first kind of trading cards to hit the market. Basketball and football cards can also be highly valuable if they belong to in-demand players. And surprisingly, rare Pokémon and other gaming cards can also command impressive prices.
What is the difference between a vintage and modern sports card?
Sports card collectors don’t always agree about what constitutes a vintage vs. modern card. For many collectors, the cutoff is 1980; cards produced before that year are vintage while cards produced after are modern. If you have a mixed collection of cards from different years, a grader can help you figure out which ones are vintage and which ones are not.7
Photo credit: iStock/smodj
Brokerage and Active investing products offered through SoFi Securities LLC, member FINRA(www.finra.org)/SIPC(www.sipc.org).
An investor should consider the investment objectives, risks, charges, and expenses of the Fund carefully before investing. This and other important information are contained in the Fund’s prospectus. For a current prospectus, please click the Prospectus link on the Fund’s respective page. The prospectus should be read carefully prior to investing.
Alternative investments, including funds that invest in alternative investments, are risky and may not be suitable for all investors. Alternative investments often employ leveraging and other speculative practices that increase an investor's risk of loss to include complete loss of investment, often charge high fees, and can be highly illiquid and volatile. Alternative investments may lack diversification, involve complex tax structures and have delays in reporting important tax information. Registered and unregistered alternative investments are not subject to the same regulatory requirements as mutual funds.
Please note that Interval Funds are illiquid instruments, hence the ability to trade on your timeline may be restricted. Investors should review the fee schedule for Interval Funds via the prospectus.
Claw Promotion: Customer must fund their Active Invest account with at least $50 within 30 days of opening the account. Probability of customer receiving $1,000 is 0.028%. See full terms and conditions.
Financial Tips & Strategies: The tips provided on this website are of a general nature and do not take into account your specific objectives, financial situation, and needs. You should always consider their appropriateness given your own circumstances.
SOIN-Q424-002