Table of Contents
Both a loan modification and a loan refinance can lower your monthly payments and help you save money. Depending on your circumstances, one strategy will make more sense than the other. A modification alters the terms of your current loan and can help you avoid default or foreclosure. Refinancing, on the other hand, involves taking out a new loan (ideally with better rates and terms) and using it to pay off your existing loan.
Here’s a closer look at loan modification vs. refinance, how each lending option works, and when to choose one or the other.
Key Points
• Loan modification changes existing terms to make payments more affordable in qualifying situations.
• Refinancing replaces the old loan, often with better rates or terms.
• Modification helps avoid default or foreclosure by making payments manageable.
• Refinancing is beneficial for those with good credit and stable income.
• Decision factors include credit impact, financial stability, loan terms, and costs.
What Is a Loan Modification?
A loan modification changes the terms of a loan to make the monthly payments more affordable. It’s a strategy that most commonly comes into play with mortgages. A home loan modification is a change in the way the home mortgage loan is structured, primarily to provide some financial relief for struggling homeowners.
Unlike refinancing a mortgage, which pays off the current home loan and replaces it with a new one, a loan modification changes the terms and conditions of the current home loan. These changes might include:
• A new repayment timetable. A loan modification may extend the term of the loan, allowing the borrower to have more time to pay off the loan.
• A lower interest rate. Loan modifications may allow borrowers to lower the interest rates on an existing loan. A lower interest rate can reduce a borrower’s monthly payment.
• Switching from an adjustable rate to a fixed rate. If you currently have an adjustable-rate loan, a loan modification might allow you to change it to a fixed-rate loan. A fixed-rate loan may be easier to manage, since it offers consistent monthly payments over the life of the loan.
A loan modification can be hard to qualify for, as lenders are under no obligation to change the terms and conditions of a loan, even if the borrower is behind on payments. A lender will typically request documents to show financial hardship, such as hardship letters, bank statements, tax returns, and proof of income.
While loan modifications are most common for secured loans, like home mortgages, it may also be possible to get modifications for unsecured loans as well, such as student loans and even personal loans.
What Is Refinancing a Loan?
A loan refinance doesn’t just restructure the terms of an existing loan — it replaces the current loan with a new loan that typically has a different interest rate, a longer or shorter term, or both. You’ll need to apply for a new loan, typically with a new lender. Once approved, you use the new loan to pay off the old loan. Moving forward, you only make payments on the new loan.
Refinancing a loan can make sense if you can:
• Qualify for a lower interest rate. The classic reason to refi any type of loan is to lower your interest rate. With home loans, however, you’ll want to consider fees and closing costs involved in a mortgage refinance, since they can eat into any savings you might get with the lower rate.
• Extend the repayment terms. Having a longer period of time to pay off a loan generally lowers the monthly payment and can relieve a borrower’s financial stress. Just keep in mind that extending the term of a loan generally increases the amount of interest you pay, increasing the total cost of the loan.
• Shorten the loan repayment time. While refinancing a loan to a shorter repayment term may increase the monthly loan payments, it can reduce the overall cost of the loan by allowing you to pay off the debt faster. This can result in significant cost savings.
Recommended: How Does a Personal Loan Work?
Refinance vs Loan Modification: Pros and Cons
Loan refinance is typically something a borrower chooses to do, whereas loan modification is generally something a borrower needs to do, often as a last resort.
Here’s a look at the pros and cons of each option.
| Loan Modification | Refinancing | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Pros | Cons | Pros | Cons |
| Avoid loan default and foreclosure | Could negatively impact credit | May be able to lower interest rate | You’ll need solid credit and income |
| Lower your monthly payment | Cash out is not an option | May be able to shorten or lengthen your loan term | Closing costs may lower overall savings |
| Avoid closing costs | Lenders not required to grant modification | May be able to turn home equity into cash | Could reset the clock on your loan |
Benefits of Loan Modification
While a loan modification is rarely a borrower’s first choice, it comes with some advantages. Here are a few to consider.
• Avoid default and foreclosure. Getting a loan modification can help you avoid defaulting on your mortgage and potentially losing your home as a result of missing mortgage payments.
• Change the loan’s terms. It may be possible to increase the length of your loan, which would lower your monthly payment. Or, if the original interest rate was variable, you might be able to switch to a fixed rate, which could result in savings over the life of the loan.
• Avoid closing costs. Unlike a loan refinance, a loan modification allows you to keep the same loan. This helps you avoid having to pay closing costs (or other fees) that come with getting a new loan.
Drawbacks of Loan Modification
Since loan modification is generally an effort to prevent foreclosure on the borrower’s home, there are some drawbacks to be aware of.
• It could have a negative effect on your credit. A loan modification on a credit report is typically a negative entry and could lower your credit score. However, having a foreclosure — or even missed payments — can be more detrimental to a person’s overall creditworthiness.
• Tapping home equity for cash is not an option. Unlike refinancing, a loan modification cannot be used to tap home equity for an extra lump sum of cash (called a cash-out refi). If your monthly payments are lower after modification, though, you may have more funds to pay other expenses each month.
• There is a hardship requirement. It’s typically necessary to prove financial hardship to qualify for loan modification. Lenders may want to see that your extenuating financial circumstances are involuntary and that you’ve made an effort to address them, or have a plan to do so, before considering loan modification.
Recommended: Guide to Mortgage Relief Programs
Benefits of Refinancing a Loan
For borrowers with a strong financial foundation, refinancing a mortgage or other type of loan comes with a number of benefits. Here are some to consider.
• You may be able to get a lower interest rate. If your credit and income are strong, you may be able to qualify for an interest rate that is lower than your current loan, which could mean a savings over the life of the loan.
• You may be able to shorten or extend the term of the loan. A shorter loan term can mean higher monthly payments but is likely to result in an overall savings. A longer loan term generally means lower monthly payments, but may increase your costs.
• You may be able to pull cash out of your home. If you opt for a cash-out refinance, you can turn some of your equity in your home into cash that you can use however you want. With this type of refinance, the new loan is for a greater amount than what is owed, the old loan is paid off, and the excess cash can be used for things like home renovations or credit card consolidation.
Drawbacks of Refinancing a Loan
Refinancing a loan also comes with some disadvantages. Here are some to keep in mind.
• You’ll need strong credit and income. Lenders who offer refinancing typically want to see that you are in a solid financial position before they issue you a new loan. If your situation has improved since you originally financed, you could qualify for better rates and terms.
• Closing costs can be steep. When refinancing a mortgage, you typically need to pay closing costs. Before choosing a mortgage refi, you’ll want to look closely at any closing costs a lender charges, and whether those costs are paid in cash or rolled into the new mortgage loan. Consider how quickly you’ll be able to recoup those costs to determine if the refinance is worth it.
• You could set yourself back on loan payoff. When you refinance a loan, you can choose a new loan term. If you’re already five years into a 30-year mortgage and you refinance for a new 30-year loan, for example, you’ll be in debt five years longer than you originally planned. And if you don’t get a lower interest rate, extending your term can increase your costs.
Is It Better to Refinance or Get a Loan Modification?
Whether a refinance or loan modification is better depends on your situation. If you have solid credit and are current on your loan payments, you’ll likely want to choose refinancing over loan modification. To qualify for a refinance, you’ll need to have a loan in good standing and prove that you make enough money to absorb the new payments.
If you’re behind on your loan payments and trying to avoid negative consequences (like loan default or foreclosure on your home), your best option is likely going to be loan modification. Provided the lender is willing, you may be able to change the rate or terms of your loan to make repayment more manageable. This may be more agreeable to a lender than having to take expensive legal action against you.
Recommended: Debt Consolidation Calculator
Alternatives to Refinancing and Loan Modification
If you’re having trouble making your mortgage payments or just looking for a way to save money on a debt, here are some other options to consider besides refinancing and loan modification.
Mortgage Forbearance
For borrowers facing short-term financial challenges, a mortgage forbearance may be an option to consider.
Lenders may grant a term of forbearance — typically three to six months, with the possibility of extending the term — during which the borrower doesn’t make loan payments or makes reduced payments. During that time, the lender also agrees not to pursue foreclosure.
As with a loan modification, proof of hardship is typically required. A lender’s definition of hardship may include divorce, job loss, natural disasters, costs associated with medical emergencies, and more.
During a period of forbearance, interest will continue to accrue, and the borrower will still be responsible for expenses such as homeowners insurance and property taxes.
At the end of the forbearance period, the borrower may have to repay any missed payments in addition to accrued interest. Some lenders may work with the borrower to set up a repayment plan rather than requiring one lump repayment.
Mortgage Recasting
With a mortgage recast, you make a lump sum payment toward the principal balance of the loan. The lender will then recast, or re-amortize, your remaining loan repayment schedule. Since the principal amount is smaller after the lump-sum payment is made, each monthly payment for the remaining life of the loan will be smaller, even though your interest rate and term remain the same.
Making Extra Principal Payments
With any type of loan, you may be able to lower your borrowing costs by occasionally (or regularly) making extra payments towards principal. This can help you pay back what you borrowed ahead of schedule and reduce your costs.
Before you prepay any type of loan, however, you’ll want to make sure the lender does not charge a prepayment penalty, since that might wipe out any savings. You’ll also want to make sure that the lender applies any extra payments you make directly towards principal (and not towards future monthly payments).
The Takeaway
If you’re interested in getting a lower interest rate, lowering your monthly debt payment, or cashing out some equity, refinancing likely makes more sense than a loan modification. If, however, you’re dealing with financial challenges and at risk of home foreclosure, you may want to look into a loan modification, which could be easier to qualify for than loan refinancing. When debt grows, you might also look into debt consolidation loans.
Think twice before turning to high-interest credit cards. Consider a SoFi personal loan instead. SoFi offers competitive fixed rates and same-day funding. See your rate in minutes.
FAQ
What are the disadvantages of loan modification?
A loan modification typically comes with a hardship requirement. A lender may ask to see proof that your financial circumstances are involuntary and that you’ve made an effort to address them before considering loan modification. A loan modification can also have a negative effect on your credit.
A loan modification can also have a temporary negative effect on your credit.
What is loan refinancing?
Loan refinancing replaces an existing loan with a new one, which pays off the old one. Then, going forward, the borrower makes payments on the new loan with its new interest rate and terms. This can help a borrower snag a lower interest rate, lower monthly payments, or shorten the loan repayment period.
Photo credit: iStock/AlexSecret
SoFi Loan Products
SoFi loans are originated by SoFi Bank, N.A., NMLS #696891 (Member FDIC). For additional product-specific legal and licensing information, see SoFi.com/legal. Equal Housing Lender.
*Awards or rankings from NerdWallet are not indicative of future success or results. This award and its ratings are independently determined and awarded by their respective publications.
Disclaimer: Many factors affect your credit scores and the interest rates you may receive. SoFi is not a Credit Repair Organization as defined under federal or state law, including the Credit Repair Organizations Act. SoFi does not provide “credit repair” services or advice or assistance regarding “rebuilding” or “improving” your credit record, credit history, or credit rating. For details, see the FTC’s website .
Financial Tips & Strategies: The tips provided on this website are of a general nature and do not take into account your specific objectives, financial situation, and needs. You should always consider their appropriateness given your own circumstances.
SOPL-Q425-033