Investment Strategy View: Learning from Earnings

By: Mario Ismailanji · May 30, 2024 · Reading Time: 4 minutes

Triumphant Returns

A common plot device in books, movies and video games is that of failure and difficulty. The protagonist often runs into an obstacle that they initially can’t get past. They spend time developing and working out their issues, before eventually overcoming their challenge.

S&P 500 companies went through such a struggle a year ago — earnings growth was negative from the fourth quarter of 2022 until the second quarter of 2023 — but there were some positive signs underneath the surface. It was around that time that the earnings surprise rate increased dramatically, and it’s important to remember that markets are forward-looking and price in available information.

Earnings alone don’t move stock prices, it’s how those results compare to investors’ expectations that drive price action. Even though the going got tough, companies showed that they could hang in there despite the headwinds.

In the latest quarter, earnings results came in 8.3% above consensus, the biggest outperformance since the fourth quarter of 2021. It’s interesting to note then, that the revenue surprise rate stood near multi-year lows at 1.0%. This tells us that unexpected margin strength has driven the boost in profitability.

Widening Margins

The margin story hasn’t been felt equally throughout the market though. While a growing share of S&P 500 companies (i.e. large-caps) have seen their net income margins beat expectations, Russell 2000 companies (i.e. small-caps) have not fared as well.

There isn’t any one explanation for why this has happened, but larger companies generally have been better positioned in the current macro environment. For one, the beneficiaries of the artificial intelligence theme have generally been large tech companies, as they’re the ones investing hundreds of billions into the technology. More broadly, however, the current high interest rate environment has a disproportionately negative effect on small-caps, as they tend to have shorter-term borrowings (i.e. inverted yield curve and higher short-term rates mean higher borrowing costs), more floating rate debt (i.e. higher fed funds rate raises borrowing costs rapidly), and lower credit ratings (i.e. lower quality raises borrowing costs).

Can David Beat Goliath?

Analysts have taken note of this dynamic, with revisions to the outlook differing for large and small companies despite strong beats from both. Compared to the start of earnings season, growth expectations for larger companies are relatively unchanged. Small-caps, however, are expected to show significantly worse earnings growth over the next four quarters than was expected before companies started reporting.

In a sense, analysts are saying that while both groups surprised positively, large companies’ results are more durable while there is doubt that small-caps are ready to emerge from their now six quarter long earnings recession. There might be a light at the end of the tunnel though, as earnings growth is expected to finally get back in positive territory in the third quarter.

While protagonists sometimes emerge all on their own, they often need some help. The same might be true for small-caps: They certainly could emerge in this environment and outperform large-caps, but it would be hard for that to happen if the macro backdrop doesn’t shift. Some developments that would probably help small-caps relative to large-caps would be the Federal Reserve cutting interest rates — absent meaningful economic weakness — or some air coming out of the AI theme that could allow small-caps to catch-up.

Until those broader macro forces shift, it’s likely that large-caps continue to be the winners in this David versus Goliath competition. But things could change later this summer if rate cuts come into focus. Don’t count David out just yet.

Want more insights from SoFi’s Investment Strategy team? The Important Part: Investing With Liz Young Thomas, a new podcast from SoFi, takes listeners through today’s top-of-mind themes in investing and breaks them down into digestible and actionable pieces.

Listen & Subscribe

Communication of SoFi Wealth LLC an SEC Registered Investment Adviser. Information about SoFi Wealth’s advisory operations, services, and fees is set forth in SoFi Wealth’s current Form ADV Part 2 (Brochure), a copy of which is available upon request and at Mario Ismailanji is a Registered Representative of SoFi Securities and Investment Advisor Representative of SoFi Wealth. His ADV 2B is available at

TLS 1.2 Encrypted
Equal Housing Lender