How Much Does Insurance Go Up After an Accident?

By Nancy Bilyeau. April 09, 2025 · 6 minute read

This content may include information about products, features, and/or services that may only be available through SoFi's affiliates and is intended to be educational in nature.

How Much Does Insurance Go Up After an Accident?

Those moments right after a car accident deliver some of the worst stress imaginable. You’re figuring out if anyone is hurt and how bad your car’s been damaged. And before too long you’re asking yourself this stomach-churning question: “How much will my insurance go up after an accident?”

There are many factors at play, including who was at fault, how serious the injuries and damage, your driving record, what state you live in, and the policies of your chosen insurance company.

Understanding these factors and digging into the forces controlling car insurance rates can help you pursue the best options possible.

Key Points

•   Car insurance rates can increase significantly after an accident, depending on the severity and fault.

•   Factors affecting rate increases include driving history, location, and type of insurance.

•   Rate increases can last for several years, impacting long-term costs.

•   Defensive driving courses and good driving records can help reduce rates.

•   Comparing quotes from multiple insurers can lead to better rates post-accident.

Why Do Rates Go Up After an Accident?

Auto insurance is a highly competitive business, and that competition plays a role in keeping rates low. But it also means that when an accident happens, there can be quite a jump in what you pay for coverage.

When you’ve had a car accident and you are at fault, your insurer now assumes you drive in a way that could cause an accident. That may sound unfair, but that’s part of how car insurance works. They are assuming a higher risk, and that is passed on to you in the form of a higher rate.

If you are found not at fault in the accident, your insurance rate may go up by a small percentage. California and Oklahoma are two states, however, that mandate insurance companies cannot raise insurance rates after an accident where the driver was not at fault.

This is yet another reason why it’s important to go over policies carefully when making your choice. It’s smart to compare the rates among top insurers and even look at how much insurance increases after an accident with various insurers.

There is one bright spot in the insurance landscape when dealing with an accident. If your insurer offers and you elect to pay for accident forgiveness, your insurance rate will not go up after your first at-fault accident. Driving record and driving experience requirements must be met before this benefit is available.

Recommended: Auto Insurance Terms, Explained

Average Rate Increases by State

After an at-fault accident, yes, your car insurance is likely to go up. Rates can increase by about 45% a year on average after an accident, according to 2025 MarketWatch research. But as the analysis below shows, just how much your rate jumps can depend on the state in which you’re insured.

Average Car Insurance Rate Increase After an At-Fault Accident

State Average rate with a clean driving record Average rate after one at-fault accident % increase
Alabama $1,775 $2,498 41%
Alaska $1,685 $2,248 33%
Arizona $2,008 $2,938 46%
Arkansas $2,038 $3,001 47%
California $2,313 $4,085 77%
Colorado $2,173 $3,040 40%
Connecticut $1,919 $2,699 41%
Delaware $2,881 $3,893 35%
Florida $3,244 $4,608 42%
Georgia $1,973 $2,931 49%
Hawaii $1,656 $2,306 39%
Idaho $1,402 $2,057 47%
Illinois $1,541 $2,193 42%
Indiana $1,587 $2,333 47%
Iowa $1,563 $2,086 33%
Kansas $1,918 $2,924 52%
Kentucky $2,522 $3,655 45%
Louisiana $3,040 $4,423 45%
Maine $1,238 $1,796 45%
Maryland $1,833 $2,958 61%
Massachusetts $2,430 $4,403 66%
Michigan $3,643 $5,204 43%
Minnesota $1,766 $2,528 43%
Mississippi $1,658 $2,603 57%
Missouri $2,104 $2,992 42%
Montana $1,979 $2,848 44%
Nebraska $1,871 $2,679 43%
Nevada $2,788 $4,112 47%
New Hampshire $1,362 $2,088 53%
New Jersey $2,513 $4,127 64%
New Mexico $1,943 $2,720 40%
New York $2,088 $2,863 37%
North Carolina $1,627 $2,756 69%
North Dakota $1,916 $2,431 27%
Ohio $1,599 $2,341 46%
Oklahoma $2,278 $3,066 35%
Oregon $1,925 $2,945 53%
Pennsylvania $1,981 $2,820 42%
Rhode Island $2,357 $2,605 11%
South Carolina $1,845 $2,496 35%
South Dakota $2,291 $3,300 44%
Tennessee $1,524 $2,227 46%
Texas $2,205 $3,365 53%
Utah $1,928 $2,855 48%
Vermont $1,199 $1,722 44%
Virginia $1,781 $2,636 48%
Washington $1,616 $2,320 44%
West Virginia $2,177 $3,195 47%
Wisconsin $1,694 $2,516 49%
Wyoming $1,702 $2,305 35%

Source: MarketWatch

How Do I Keep My Rates Low After an Accident?

If you’ve had a car accident, there are some things you may be able to do to keep your car insurance rates from rising.

First, explore discounts that you may have overlooked. Check with your insurer to make sure you’re receiving discounts you’re eligible for.

•   If you haven’t already signed up for paperless billing, now might be a good time to take advantage of the discount you may receive with this option.

•   The number of miles you drive annually is one factor that goes into calculating your insurance rate. Check with your insurer to make sure your rate correctly reflects your annual mileage.

•   Consider a usage-based insurance that tracks different elements of your driving habits and sets your rate accordingly. Better driving habits typically equate to lower rates.

•   Ask about multi-policy discounts if you have all your policies with one insurer.

•   Check into military and government employee discounts.

Another tactic that might be worth pursuing if you’ve had an accident but are looking for ways to decrease your car insurance rate is to increase your deductible. The higher your deductible, the lower your premium.

Look into how much insurance you’re carrying on the car. It’s worth your time to determine how much coverage you need. If your car is worth less than the deductible plus your annual total for car insurance, it could be time to rethink your coverage.

And another thing to scrutinize is what kind of car you drive. Some cars are cheaper to insure than others.

When Does Car Insurance Go Down After an Accident?

Generally speaking, it takes three to five years for car insurance to go down following most at-fault accidents. The insurers are going by the statistical wisdom that if you’re in one accident, the chances are higher that you will be in another. Some insurers also take into account the seriousness of the accident and whether impaired driving was a factor in the accident.

One tactic people employ to lower their rates is to shop around for a new insurer. While the record of the accident and claim will be visible to a second insurer, you may still be able to get better deals.

Your insurance rates will also be affected by your credit. Merely being involved in an accident will not damage your credit, but an improvement in your credit score can be used as leverage in getting a lower premium.

Don’t rule out getting a brushup on your driving to improve those skills. Some insurance companies will discount your rates if you complete a defensive driving or driver education course.

Recommended: Car Insurance Guide for New Drivers

The Takeaway

that can seem hard to figure out. Rates can go up by about 45% a year on average after an accident. But that figure may fluctuate depending on a variety of factors including who was at fault, the seriousness of the accident, your driving record, and to a surprising degree, the state in which you live.

Taking the opportunity to compare car insurance companies before committing to a policy can be a smart move that might save you money on your insurance rate.

When you’re ready to shop for auto insurance, SoFi can help. Our online auto insurance comparison tool lets you see quotes from a network of top insurance providers within minutes, saving you time and hassle.

SoFi brings you real rates, with no bait and switch.


Photo credit: iStock/simpson33

Auto Insurance: Must have a valid driver’s license. Not available in all states.
Home and Renters Insurance: Insurance not available in all states.
Experian is a registered trademark of Experian.
SoFi Insurance Agency, LLC. (“”SoFi””) is compensated by Experian for each customer who purchases a policy through the SoFi-Experian partnership.


Third-Party Brand Mentions: No brands, products, or companies mentioned are affiliated with SoFi, nor do they endorse or sponsor this article. Third-party trademarks referenced herein are property of their respective owners.

Financial Tips & Strategies: The tips provided on this website are of a general nature and do not take into account your specific objectives, financial situation, and needs. You should always consider their appropriateness given your own circumstances.

SOPRO-Q225-020

TLS 1.2 Encrypted
Equal Housing Lender